14 Comments

I would want my Seven Sorrows devotional booklet and Rosary.

Expand full comment

Crucifix, Rosary, Brown Scapular, my Latin Mass missal, and my Douay-Rheims Bible.

Expand full comment

I've have heard that the Douay-Rheims translation is more poetic than other translations and that is a Bible made by Catholics for Catholics. I only have my RSV and RSV Study Bible but the DR Bible has been popping up in my radar a lot more. What do you like about it?

Expand full comment

The Douay-Rheims was THE Catholic English Bible for centuries. I like that it's based on St. Jerome's Vulgate, and it's certainly withstood the test of time. I also like the more archaic wording of it. In high school, I read the RSV-CE because the archaic language of the DR was too overwhelming for me at the time, but I've since grown to love the DR. It's now my Bible of choice; I only use the RSV-CE for very rare moments in my writing, when I feel that a certain wording choice might be better understood by my readers. The DR also the Bible from which the English translation of the Latin Mass readings are taken, which I appreciate. If you're ever looking to add a new Catholic Bible to your collection, I highly, highly recommend the DR!

Expand full comment

1. Crucifix

2. Rosary/Seven Sorrows Chaplet

3. Journal and pen (my journal has a pen holder so it obviously only counts as one item)

4. Icons

5. Relics

Expand full comment

Oh man, I can already see it..."Castaway Chronicles."

Expand full comment

Five Christian brothers.

Expand full comment

This is a creative and excellent answer!

Expand full comment

Day 5: We have built a Church.

Expand full comment

LOL

Expand full comment

So good!

Expand full comment

Just wanted to say that I really enjoyed this conversation. For someone in the very early stages of converting this felt like I was listening to a conversation between two slightly older but wiser brothers whom I admire. Much of this was over my head but I still found interesting and useful.

Expand full comment

So glad I finally made time to listen to this. Definitely information here that is absolutely new to me but fascinating. I really appreciate the casual way you and Walther approach these topics. It can feel a bit overwhelming as a convert to learn of all the "stuff" but it's helpful to hear how casually you both picked up on these things and simply incorporated them into your life.

Also, a comment from a very recent convert... not even in RCIA yet..

But I have never understood the major objections to the crucifix, even while I was protestant. I know a few people who reject seeing one and say things like, "It really irks me to see Jesus on the cross because he's not there anymore. He's risen!" It's a strange idea, to me, that one can take a recognition of his sacrifice and somehow see it as against the resurrection. It's some kind of weird either or type thinking..

But I told my wife at some point that, ya know, lots of people in history were crucified. It was a horrible means of death but Jesus was not the only person who died on a cross. HOWEVER, Jesus was the only one who was killed by crucifixion who voluntarily did so for the salvation of the world. All that to say, it's not the cross itself that matters but the God who died on it for us means everything. So even as a protestant, that's why the crucifix never bothered me. But I guess I'm weird for that... hahah

Expand full comment

I mean, we venerate relics so if you think you're weird, you're in good company.

Expand full comment